Soy Protein Vs Pea Protein


Share post:

The Tricky Science Behind Texture And Mouthfeel

Consider This Before Buying Your Protein Powder!

Crumbly, chalky, gristly. These were some of the words used to describe plant-based meats in their early days. Making meat out of plant protein powder and stabilizers was and still is no easy feat.

So, how exactly are plant protein powders used in plant-based meats? To provide the base for the product, protein powder is mixed with water, forming a solid but malleable mass. At this point, however, the mixture doesnt have the ability to hold itself together as well as animal-based meat does. Hence, stabilizers and emulsifiers must be added to give it the desired mouthfeel and texture. Through constant tests and trials, plant-based meats have steadily improved in terms of texture and taste. Nevertheless, different plant-based proteins still yield different results when it comes to texture and mouthfeel.

Products like Beyond Meats plant-based patties are starting to show up on fast food menus .

Since both soy and chickpea protein isolate have a better emulsifying capacity than pea, that also means lower amounts of stabilizers need to be added. Why then would someone choose to use pea protein?

Soy Vs Pea Protein Definitive Guide To Which One Is Best

*This site contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.*

Are your trying to choose between soy and pea protein? Nowaday, there are a lot of vegan protein powders you can choose from, so its no wonder that people find it difficult to decide which one to buy. From soy and pea protein to rice, hemp, sunflower, and pumpkin seed protein, avoiding animal-based protein supplements has never been easier.

While soy and pea protein are the two main plant-based proteins that are jockeying for dominance in the protein powder industry, if youre looking to make the switch but arent sure which one to go with stick around to find out everything there is to know about these types of protein supplements so you can decide which one would work best for you.

Elm & Rye Pre Workout

Image courtesy Elm & Rye

Elm & Rye pre-workout products, which include caffeine, Beta Alanine, Ashwagandha, B12 , Reishi , and CoQ10, are designed to help you focus during exercise by increasing energy, attention, endurance, and muscular growth through our combination of adaptogenic and lab-tested compounds.

This pre-workout is based on scientific research and will help you train more effectively and quickly recover from workouts.

Not only does Beta Alanine relieve post-workout muscle soreness, but it also allows athletes to perform at their peak for longer periods of time. With regular use, Ashwagandha has been shown to increase not just strength, but also muscle mass and reduction in body fat percentage in men.

Don’t Miss: Drink Protein To Lose Weight

The Health Benefits Of Pea Protein Powder

Pea protein powder is hypo-allergenic. It is free from the 8 main allergens, one of which is soy. It has a complete amino acid profile. And is high in arginine, which helps with blood flow and heart health. It also contains good levels of the essential amino acids leucine, isoleucine and valine which play critical roles in the regulation of energy homeostasis, metabolism, gut health, immunity and disease .

Further to this it is a good source of iron making it a quick and effective way to top up iron levels each day. For those looking to reduce their weight, pea protein powder can be a great way to do this. Additionally its mix of fibre resistant starch components help to suppress appetite and glycemia .

Pea protein has been found to be more effective than all protein powders aside from casein protein when it comes to suppressing appetite when used as a pre-load. This effect of making individuals consume less calorie after taking pea protein has lead to many using pea protein for weight loss goals.

The Nutritional Value Of Soy Protein

Pea vs Soy Protein: Which Protein is Right for You?  Nuzest USA

Soy protein powder is created from defatted flakes of soybean, which are cleaned with water or alcohol to remove all the dietary fiber and sugars. Afterward, the flakes are dehydrated and transformed into a powdery form.

Soy protein powder doesnt include any cholesterol and has an extremely low amount of fat. 20 grams of soy protein powder contains the following nutritional value:

  • Magnesium 10.9 mg

While it is a great protein source, it also includes phytates that are known to reduce the absorption of minerals.

Don’t Miss: What Does C Reactive Protein Indicate

Soy Vs Whey Vs Pea Protein: Which One Is Best

Soy vs. Whey vs. pea protein. Suppose youve ever wondered which one is best if youre not alone! Variety can be a wonderful thing, but when it comes to protein supplements, there are so many to choose from its hard to know where to start.

Not all protein sources are created equal, so as a consumer, its important to know what youre getting, as well as the pros and cons. In this guide, well break down the differences between soy vs whey vs pea protein so you can make an educated decision about which type of protein will help you achieve your fitness goals.

Is Pea Protein Good For You And Is It Healthier Than Soy

  • Medical Reviewer: Mahammad Juber, MD

Medically Reviewed on 10/10/2022

  • Related Resources – Is Pea Protein Good for You, and Is It Healthier Than Soy?
  • Pea protein is a product that comes from yellow split peas. Dietary proteins are necessary for survival. You can get them from many different sources including most plants and animals. Many people rely on animals for their main dietary protein source, but plant-based proteins are an increasingly popular part of Western diets.

    Both pea and soy proteins come from plants. This means that theyre more similar to one another than they are to animal protein sources. But there are still significant differences between these two products.

    You May Like: Whey Protein Gold Standard 10 Lbs

    Pea Vs Soy Protein Nutrition: Is Soy Protein Good For You Is Pea Protein Good For You

    Soy protein offers a major advantage over many other plant-based proteins: it contains a full amino acid profile². Most other plant-based protein powders on the market do not offer a complete array of all essential amino acids necessary for human nutrition, giving soy protein an amino acid edge over many other vegan protein powder competitors.

    Pea protein also has a nearly complete amino acid profile. Clean Lean Protein, a high-quality, premium golden pea protein isolate is a 100% vegan protein that contains all the essential amino acids.

    Both soy and pea protein are wise choices when in the market for high-quality, plant-based proteins rich with amino acids.

    Soy protein is often praised for its health benefits. Soy contains isoflavones³, which are a family of phytochemical compounds, are often touted for their health benefits. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration4has also authorized the use of food labels to make health claims associated with soy protein and a reduced risk of coronary heart disease, based on studies that have shown intake of 25 grams of soy protein each day in combination with a low-fat diet results in reductions of LDL cholesterol levels.

    Both soy and pea protein powders typically contain between 17-22 grams of protein per 100 calorie serving . Clean Lean Protein by Nuzest, for instance, contains 18-21 grams of protein per serving, depending on flavor.

    Who Should Use Pea Protein

    Which Vegan Protein Powder is Best?

    There are many great reasons to incorporate pea protein into your diet. These include:

    • Building muscle. Using pea protein supplements along with a rigorous resistance training program can help you build and strengthen muscles. Pea protein isolates are best for this use because they contain the highest concentration of pure protein.
    • Losing weight. You can take pea protein 30 minutes before a meal to help suppress your appetite. Some people also use them as meal substitutes. In this case, pea protein concentrates are a better product because they contain a more balanced array of nutrients than isolates.
    • Watching your health. Plant proteins are a great way to get proteins into your diet without relying on red meat. Overeating red meat can increase your risk of developing certain health problems. Pea protein may even help lower your blood pressure something red meat doesnt do.

    Like other plant-derived proteins, pea proteins are compatible with vegetarian and vegan diets. Theyre also great for people with most food allergies. Theyre safe for everyone with the most common food allergies. This includes people who are allergic to:

    Don’t Miss: Protein Rich Food For Veg

    How Much Actual Protein Is In Pea Protein

    One cup of yellow peas on their own contain about 8 grams of protein, says DiMarino. But one scoop of pea protein isolate the protein powder youd buy at a store contains between 15 and 20 grams of protein for every 100 calories.

    To put that in perspective, the recommended dietary allowance of protein for an adult is about 0.8 grams per kilogram of your body weight. For example, a 175-pound man would need about 63 grams of protein a day. If youre active, youll need a little more.

    In other words, pea protein powder packs a powerful punch, particularly as a dietary supplement.

    All You Need To Know About Pea Protein

    Pea protein powder is made after extracting the protein content from yellow peas. It is mostly utilized to enhance the content of protein in shakes and smoothies. It is not just a good source of protein, but also contains a high amount of iron.

    Pea protein enhances your heart health, aids weight loss, and increases muscle growth. Many individuals use pea protein powder as a post-workout beverage by mixing it in water, juices, or smoothies. It can also be added to cereals, porridge, oatmeal, and even baked goods.

    You May Like: Vega Protein Powder Weight Loss

    A Few Final Tips For Choosing A High

    When youre looking to buy a protein supplement, be sure to read the product label carefully. Of course, you want a product thats high in protein, but you also want to choose a product thats free of cheap fillers, refined sugar, and artificial ingredients.

    Choosing products that are made in the USA is also a good idea, especially when it comes to plant proteins like soy and pea. Other countries arent kept to the same standards American farmers are, and foreign products may have been grown in soil thats contaminated with heavy metals.

    To ensure that youre getting the best value for your money when purchasing a protein powder, check the label to see how many servings the package contains. Avoid products with low protein content and a low number of servings per container. For the most benefit, you want at least 18g of protein per serving.

    Choosing The Right Protein Powder: Whey Vs Pea Vs Soy

    Pea Protein vs Soy Protein

    Are you struggling to decide which protein powder is best for you? Who said variety is overrated? Protein supplements are so varied that it can often times confuse shoppers. Not only do we have to choose between whey, pea, and soy protein, but each protein also comes in multiple flavors! Feeling overwhelmed yet?

    Naturade is here with a guide to use when shopping for a protein powder. This guide compares the different kinds of protein powder that are out there! Now you will know if whey, pea, or soy is the best choice for you.

    Naturades Cheat Sheet: Shopping for protein powders is easy if you follow our checklist.

  • Understand that there are different types of protein
  • Identify your dietary restrictions and choose a base protein
  • Choose a flavor or variation of added ingredients
  • Not sure which protein is right for you? Let us break down the differences between whey, pea and soy protein using our products as a reference. Usually proteins are either vegetable or animal source proteins. Whey protein is animal-based, while soy protein and pea protein are derived from vegetables.. Many people feel that animal proteins taste better, making them more popular. Whey also has more varieties and has been around longer. People who choose plant protein generally do so as a lifestyle choice. Pea protein or soy protein may be right for you because of the added health benefits or as a result of dietary restrictions.

    Whey Protein:

    Pea Protein:

    Soy Protein:

    Recommended Reading: High Urine Protein Creatinine Ratio

    What Is Pea Protein

    Pea protein is a protein supplement made from yellow split peas. It is mostly found in energy bars, veggie burgers, meal-replacement shakes, and even cereals.

    It is used to boost protein intake and has been gaining popularity in vegetarians and vegans who are looking for a healthy, dairy-free option when it comes to protein supplements.

    Unlike soy protein, pea protein has a nearly complete amino acid profile. While it has all 9 essential amino acids in its profile, it is low in one of them and thats methionine.

    What this means is that you should take it as one of your protein sources, but not as your major choice. However, theres a way around this and well discuss it in detail below.

    Aside from being a good source of high-quality protein, peas are a great source of iron. Pea protein is also high in fiber, helping keep you full for a longer time, while also benefiting gastrointestinal health.

    Studies have shown that pea protein is more satiating than whey protein, making it a better choice for those who are looking to control their appetite.

    Note: Since iron found in plant-based foods is not as easily absorbable as the one found in animal products, combine your pea protein powder with vitamin C for greater absorption.

    The Bottom Line On Pea Protein

    Pea protein is one of the unsung heroes among plant-based protein powders.

    • Its mostly protein by weight and high in essential amino acids .
    • Its well digested and absorbed.
    • It tastes pleasant and mixes well with water.

    Its Achilles heel is the amino acid methionine, which its short on, but this is easily mitigated by eating a balanced diet or combining it with rice protein, as weve done with Plant+.

    All this is why a pea protein powder is just as viable of an option for supplementation as anything else, including the heavy hitters like whey and casein.

    Recommended Reading: Best Whey Isolate Protein Powder

    Soy Vs Pea Protein: Best For Muscle Gain

    Both soy and pea protein are great choices when it comes to plant-based proteins, as they are rich in essential amino acids, which are typically known as the building blocks of protein, necessary for muscle growth and recovery.

    However, soy protein isolate is a complete protein, containing all 9 essential amino acids, while pea protein is low in one important essential amino acid methionine.

    For this reason, combining pea protein with other protein sources which are rich in methionine is important and even necessary in making a complete protein. One of the easiest ways to achieve that is to consume methionine-rich foods, like brown rice, quinoa, oats, sunflower seeds, hemp, and so on. Combining these protein sources at the same time is not necessary, as long as you have a nice balance of essential amino acids over the course of the day.

    While pea protein may be lacking in methionine, it has a high leucine and arginine content and is thus great at promoting muscle growth.

    The Health Benefits Of Soy Protein

    Whey Protein VS Pea Protein: do they compare?

    Consuming soy protein powder not only increases the amount of protein absorbed but also provides a good source of fats. Soy protein is rich in vitamin B – potassium minerals and magnesium. As studies have shown, all soybean varieties accumulate polyphenols. Polyphenols are a type of antioxidant that helps to protect your organs from damage including serious conditions such as heart disease. Some research suggests it can aid in weight loss through soy protein.

    Don’t Miss: High Protein Breakfast Low Calorie

    Global Supply Issues And New Formulations Could Shake Up The Market

    As it currently stands, soy protein is the cheapest while chickpea is the most expensive. This could also explain why most products in the Pinto database and on the market contain soy protein/flour while chickpea protein is only used in 5% of the products. Chickpea protein is still expensive because, unlike the other two, the demand is not yet high enough to achieve lower production costs. However, chickpea protein makers argue that there is a price trade-off that comes with using chickpea protein. Since the protein is highly functional, more so than soy or pea protein, this means that lesser amounts of stabilizers or emulsifiers are needed to bind or stabilize the product. Moreover, due to its neutral flavor profile, less flavoring is needed to mask the taste of the protein. Thus, both these factors should lower production costs of the product and make the more expensive chickpea protein a viable option.

    As long as the product is readily available and prices for it remain low, companies that currently use soy protein might not be motivated to aggressively seek alternatives such as pea or chickpea protein. However, something to keep in mind is that the pandemic has caused some disruption in the logistics and production chain, which could eventually cause prices of soybean protein to increase even if the price of soybean itself is lower.

    Soybean prices hit historical lows last year due to the trade war between China and the U.S.

    Transparent Labs Whey Protein Isolate

    Image courtesy Transparent Labs

    This vendor’s first product in the ProteinSeries is the 100% Grass-Fed Whey Protein Isolate sourced from grass fed American Cows! It has one of the industrys highest protein-by-weight ratios at 88% .

    Transparent Labs 100% Grass-Fed Whey Protein Isolate is made from naturally fed, hormone-free cow whey and is free of artificial sweeteners, colors, gluten, and preservatives. It’s one of the cleanest proteins available.

    If you want to build muscle or lose weight, protein is an essential tool that will help you achieve your goals. It’s perfect for post-workout recovery and hitting daily protein targets.

    Read Also: Iso 100 Protein Powder Cocoa Pebbles

    Related articles

    How Much Protein Needed Per Day

    Where Does Protein Come From ...

    High Protein Breakfast Recipes For Weight Loss

    Basic Breakfast: Homemade Muffin 7...

    Lose Weight High Protein Diet

    How Much Protein Should I Eat Daily ...