What Should You Remember
As you can see for yourself, there is no one right answer to the question whether it is better to drink protein with water or milk. Different situations call for different solutions. And likewise, different people have different needs. Thats why its always important to think about what your goal is and what you expect from protein in a particular instance.
It may then be more appropriate to choose a particular liquid accordingly. However, keep in mind that protein, whether with milk or water, will only make up a smaller portion of your daily caloric intake. And which fluid you use is more of a minor detail and doesnt have that much of an impact on your overall results. So focus on making sure you have enough of the necessary protein in your diet overall, and then work on these little details.
Do you have someone in your group of friends who is afraid of mixing protein with milk? Share this article with them so that they can find out they dont have to be afraid of this combination.
Bernaciková, M., Masarykova univerzita, & Fakulta sportovních studií. Regenerace a výiva ve sportu
Ralf Jäger et al. International Society of Sports Nutrition Position Stand: protein and exercise
Kim J. et al. Effects of dietary protein intake on body composition changes after weight loss in older adults: A systematic review and meta-analysis.
Who Should Mix Protein Powder With Milk
Since there are different types of milk that you can use, you can control the number of calories depending on your goals.
For example, if you are looking to increase muscle mass, you can choose to use whole milk. If you are looking to cut body fat, choose to use skim milk to help hit your protein goals easier.
Protein Powder For Kids
This post may contain affiliate links. If you shop from one of our links, we may earn a commission.
Learn if protein powder for kids is safe, how to boost protein without expensive powders, and which store bought brands are best. With answers to frequently asked questions about protein and easy recipes to try.
Recommended Reading: Does Protein Build Muscle Without Working Out
Have You Considered Plant Based Milk
If you love the smooth silky texture and taste milk gives to your protein shake but dont want too many extra calories added then maybe plant-based is the way forward. You may be sat there thinking, ew I wouldnt add that to my shake, but youll be pleasantly surprised by its taste, texture and nutritionals too. For example, 200ml of almond milk contains 44 calories, 2.2g of fat, 4.8g of sugar and 0.8g of protein, while also containing 240mg of calcium. Starting to make a little more sense now. You could also try hazelnut milk too which contains 58 calories, 3.2g of fat, 6.2g of sugar and 0.8g of protein too. Theyre both also incredibly similar to the texture and smoothness of cows milk, you probably wont even be able to tell the difference.
What Food Should I Be Eating
It’s vital that you realise protein shakes should never replace real foods. Ever. Protein shakes are supplements, and they are there to do just that to supplement your diet. They are add-ons. Additional extras to help you reach your daily protein fix. Yes, we know, consuming a shed load of protein every day isn’t easy. But it’s important you don’t cut corners.
Protein shakes will never hold the same nutritional benefits as real food, which will generally contain more protein per serving than a shake.
Great-tasting breakfasts, lunches and dinners consisting of a healthy balance of proteins, carbohydrates and fats are full of vital minerals and vitamins that will strengthen the body and help it grow. They needn’t be complicated either. Here’s a list of a few of our favourites. If you’re struggling with food ideas, check out our protein sources food guides below:
Also Check: How To Remove Protein From Urine
What Should I Use In My Daily Protein Shake Milk Or Water
Weve talked about protein shake benefits for a swimmers diet, like when to drink them, the different types of protein, and how they can help with recovery. So a good question to ask is, what should you be mixing into your protein shake, milk or water?
The first thing you should ask yourself is, what are you aiming to achieve? Do you want to get extra nutrition and calories or would you rather hydrate more? Is taste a possible concern?
What Are The Benefits Of A Protein Shake
Whey protein supplements are simply made up of powdered whey protein that is designed to be mixed with a liquid of your choice.
These supplements are a convenient way to increase your daily protein intake, which is needed to support muscle growth, development, and a whole host of other bodily functions.
While many of us can get enough protein through diet alone, a protein shake would be ideal for those who have a higher protein requirement, such as athletes, and for those who follow a plant-based diet thus slightly lacking dietary protein.
Whey protein supplements are very accessible and cheap to buy, with most of them providing the ideal amino acid profile and a substantial dose of good quality, milk-derived protein.
So, which liquid should you be mixing it with: water or milk?
Don’t Miss: Alani Nu Munchies Protein Powder
What To Mix Protein Powder With
For the purpose of this article, I am going to focus on whey protein due to popular demand. However, whatever goes for whey protein is usually the case for other protein powders too. If you can mix whey protein, it is likely you can mix your other types of protein too. Feel free to use this article for guidance.
Milk Or Water Protein Shakes
If you’ve started drinking a smoothie in the morning or after working out, you might be wondering if you should use water or milk for a protein shake. They both serve the purpose of adding liquid to the mix, so the decision really comes down to personal preference and dietary needs.
Video of the Day
The decision to use milk or water for protein shakes depends on a variety of factors including desired calorie content, taste, dietary needs and convenience.
Read Also: What Foods Are Low In Protein
You Can Mix Protein Powder With Just About Anything
Make a protein shake.
Grab a blender and mix protein powder with milk , fruit, and nut butter. My favorite recipe is protein powder, oat milk, frozen banana, and spoonful of peanut butter. If you like thick shakes, add a handful of ice cubes.
Sick of protein shakes?
Protein shakes can get old. If you are looking for another way to boost your protein intake, try making protein oatmeal or protein yogurt. You can also add protein powder into your favorite baked goods. In many cases, a scoop or two of protein powder will not changed the recipe.
Can you mix protein powder with coffee?
You can definitely mix protein powder with coffee, but it is easier said than done. Protein powder and coffee are not exactly a match made in heaven, and adding protein powder to a hot cup of coffee with only a spoon will make a lumpy mess. To avoid this, follow these instructions. They can be used to add protein powder to other hot drinks like hot chocolate too.
Can you mix protein powder with water?
Some people like to mix protein powder with just water. The advantage of doing so is that water does not add calories, fat, etc., so what you see on the Nutrition Facts is what you get. This is great if you are counting calories, but it leaves a lot to be desired in terms of taste. In other words, by choosing to mix your protein shake with just water, you are sacrificing flavor and texture for fewer calories. As someone who likes a rich, creamy protein shake, I always mix my protein powder with milk.
How Much Protein Do Kids Need
They break it down even more and shares that kids aged 4-9 need about 19 grams of protein . That amount is covered if a child has 3 cups of milk a day or one serving of Greek yogurt.
Eating normally with a mix of whole foods may wind up with a protein amount higher than that number they offer, but their main point is that most kids dont need more protein on top of what theyre already getting.
This is not to say that anyone needs to actually count, simply to remind us all that there is a lot of protein in foods kids normally eat.
TIP: Find a full list of protein-rich foods for kids for easy reference.
Read Also: Best Sources Of Plant Based Protein
Milk Vs Water Protein Shakes For Increasing Lean Muscle Mass And For Weight Loss
When it comes to wanting to build muscle mass your whey protein shake can be supercharged by mixing a scoop with your favourite milk of choice. Whey protein in particular is renowned for promoting muscle protein synthesis, which is the primary focus when wanting to put on some size.
In this instance, and as we have noted earlier, the additional calories from whole milk, semi-skimmed milk or plant based milk will only aid in the process. Although the absorption of the protein can be slightly hindered by mixing with milk, overall the additional calories and macronutrients that you shake will provide will outweigh that factor.
When it comes to weight loss, mixing your protein powder with water is often the most ideal choice. Protein water yields less calories overall, does not hinder the absorption and digestion rate of the product itself and still has a satiety effect.
If your protein intake is inadequate and you are mindful of your calories, then mixing with water will add a high quality protein hit minus additional unwanted calories.
Milk Vs Water: The Verdict
So now weve heard the case for and against water and milk, its time to deliver a final verdict. Which formulation is best? The honest answer is that it really depends on your goals. To avoid excess calorie consumption and bloatedness, most people would be best to stick to water. When you take whey protein with milk, the proteins are absorbed slowly, which could be a good solution in the morning or at bedtime. But when you take protein after training, fast absorption is preferable, for which water is better suited.
If youre taking whey protein on a regular basis, youre already winning. Train hard and incorporate whey protein into a healthy diet and youll be well on your way to building a body you can be proud of.
Read Also: High Protein Foods For Pregnancy
Does Protein Make You Full
No matter what your workout schedule, you can keep satisfied with a dose of whey protein in the morning on an empty stomach. High-protein diets are link to appetite control and satiety. When you choose a whey protein that doesnt have added sugar or fillers, youre getting a low-calorie breakfast that will keep you going all day long.
Alternatively, you can work out while fasting and consume whey protein immediately afterward. The researchers conclude that this may be of value in helping people stick to a low-calorie diet for weight loss. Since whey protein may make you feel full and reduce your appetite without affecting your lean muscle mass or maintenance. A published report in The European Journal of Nutrition in November 2016 demonstrated that consuming whey protein after resistance training can reduce later calorie intake.
Protein Powder With Milk Or Water
It has been scientifically proven that we all have a primal need to get our protein intake, and what better way than to have a protein powder with the milk or water that is right for you.
Milk and water are both great sources of protein, and when combined they are great alternatives to the traditional protein powder. Milk has lots of protein, so you dont have to worry about the calories or the carbs. But water is more easily digestible and has less calories than milk, so you can get a more balanced protein without having to trade up on quality.
Protein powder with milk or water is a great way to get the nutrients that you really want without paying a lot of extra for a product that may not have enough of those nutrients. Its also a great way to add variety to your diet. If youre a fan of peanut butter, you can use this as an alternative to cream cheese.
A common problem in protein powder is that its a lot of calories too. Because the nutrients are absorbed quickly, you can get the nutrients you need with a much smaller amount of protein. But if you want to get all the nutrients you can eat with less, protein powder with milk or water is a great choice.
So do you need protein powder with milk or water? Yes. But protein powder with milk or water is only recommended for people with low blood pressure. Otherwise, protein powder with milk or water just makes your blood pressure rise.
Don’t Miss: Protein Shake As Meal Replacement
Protein Powder With Water
The easiest and most affordable way to make a protein shake is with water. In fact, the recipe on most product labels uses water as the liquid. Although, many also say you can use water or milk for a protein shake.
You can use protein powder with water in a blender, a shaker bottle or if you don’t mind a few clumps, simply add it to a regular water bottle and stir or shake until most of the clumps are dissolved.
A basic protein shake with water recipe will likely include the following ingredients:
- 1 scoop of protein powder
- 1 cup of cold water
- 1 to 1 1/2 cups of frozen fruit
- To make: Add all ingredients to a blender and blend on smoothie speed or low to medium until desired consistency is reached.
When on the go, some people opt for a shaker bottle to make protein shakes. This is a plastic, reusable water bottles with a lid that has a metal blender ball in the bottle that mixes the ingredients when you shake the bottle.
If you’re using one of these to mix protein powder with water, consider using cold water from the refrigerator, especially if you like a cool drink. You can add ice to keep it chilled, but it will not add to the consistency of the shake.
Things You Must Remember Take Away From The Article
1. It will be a loss to companies if you try to fulfill your protein requirements from foods alone.
2. You can add milk to whey as long as you are not on a Ketogenic diet.
3. Bulking or cutting has nothing to do with using milk or not.
4. A mixture of slow and fast acting protein or blend has been shown to be better than whey alone.
5. Post workout meal doesn`t have to be a protein shake. Solid meal consisting of lean protein and carbohydrates will also do.
6. Unless you want to replace the calories coming from milk with other foods, you don`t have to ditch your creamy milk protein shake.
7. Fast digesting protein post workout is of less importance and is in no way better than a bit slower released protein .
8. Using Whey Protein in Milk doesn`t mean it is getting wasted.
A Couple Of Researches You Can Go Through, If You Still Doubt This Information
Also Check: Vegetarian Food With High Protein
Ought To You Have A Protein Shake With Milk Or Water
Were going to keep away from sitting on the fence right here, so excuse us once we start by saying it relies upon. There isnt only one profit to every approach there are a number of, but it surely actually does depend upon what your goals are.
When constructing mass and muscle, mixing your protein with milk will yield higher outcomes. For lean builders, trimmers and toners, water is the way in which to go. It comes all the way down to diet, as thats precisely why youre ingesting protein shakes within the first place.
Milk Vs Water Protein Shakes For Bulking & Cutting
Maintaining a calorie surplus to build muscle mass during the bulking phase will give you ample room for the additional calories in a milk-based protein shake. Depending on the size of your surplus, you can use whole milk and add in some extras like bananas and nuts. If youre cutting, youre better off using a water base and skipping most of the add-ins.
If you arent cutting severely and want to mix protein powder with milk, consider the fat content of different types of cows milk:
- Whole Milk 3.5% Fat
- Semi-Skimmed Milk 1.7% 2% Fat
- Skimmed Milk < 0.3%
These numbers will vary with brand, but you can tell from these general categories that skim milk is best for weight loss and cutting while semi-skimmed will work for a maintenance diet and whole milk is optimal to gain muscle during a bulking phase.
Helpful Hint: Shred fat during a cutting phase with our Body Elevate Fitplan!
Recommended Reading: Ascent Native Fuel Whey Protein Powder Reviews
Should You Mix Your Protein With Water Or Milk
Can protein powder be a good start?
For a lot of gym-goers, protein is essential and thats where protein powders and shakes come into use for a lot of vegetarians. Whey protein, in particular, is a good source of natural nutrition derived out of whey, which is the liquid part of milk left behind during the production of cheese. Since it contains all nine essential amino acids and is fairly low on the lactose content, it can be a convenient way to replace whole foods. Whether youre a serious athlete, a bodybuilder or simply an average person looking to lose some weight and gain muscle, introducing more protein into your diet can help you achieve your goals. While protein can be found naturally in many foods like meat, eggs, beans and cheese, protein powders are a convenient, quick, and tasty way to get more protein into your diet and can be a good start. But when it comes to how you prepare your protein shake, there are some debates as to whether its better to make your protein shake with water or milk. Ultimately, the decision you make will all depend on your own personal goals.
Should you mix your protein powder with milk or water?
According to experts, the real difference between protein shakes mixed in water or milk lies in your own personal preference and the fitness goal you want to achieve- whether you want a bulked-up body, gain muscle mass or simply lose weight, flab and build on lean muscles.