Are Protein Shakes Meal Replacements


Share post:

Ask About The Calories

Best Meal Replacement Shakes (UPDATED!) What’s Best for You?!

When people consume too many calories, they gain weight, but if they dont eat enough calories, they experience fatigue, nutrient deficiencies, and more. So before you buy the lowest calorie meal replacement on the market because you want to lose weight, ask yourself if its enough to keep hunger at bay and lower the odds of you overeating later. For some people, theyll eat one or two large meals after taking one or two meal replacements, and it works wonders for them. For others, theyll have 90-calorie shakes and wind up so hungry and unsatisfied that they binge later.

Can You Live On Just Meal Replacements

So can you really replace a meal with powder? It depends on who you ask. There have been quite a few meal replacements out there that have aspired to completely replace food and encourage consumers to live on nothing but their product.

That has now become pretty uncommon, with the consensus leaning toward what became one of Soylents slogans: it shouldnt replace every meal, but it can replace any meal.

Is that a good idea? Its complicated, but theres pretty decent evidence that meal replacements can be smart for certain consumers. A meta-analysis of six randomized controlled trials, published in the International Journal of Obesity and Related Metabolic Disorders, found that adding one of these products into a low-calorie diet that part is important can safely and effectively produce significantsustainable weight loss and improve weight-related risk factors of disease.

Like a 2018 randomized controlled trial published in Nutrition & Health, multiple studies have also suggested they can be effective at helping to manage Type 2 diabetes, perhaps by helping with calorie control or blood sugar levels.

That said, there are many ingredients in whole foods that arent vitamins or minerals but are still healthful. Meal replacements will often have all the essential vitamins and minerals. However, certain antioxidants and phytonutrients are more abundant in whole foods.

Requirements Of A Meal Replacement

Currently, there are no proper regulations for a Meal Replacement product in The United States for total diet replacement or even partial replacement. You can see these Shakes marketed and regulated medical foods, conventional foods, and foods for distinct dietary use.

However, in Europe, Meal Replacements are intended to do what theyre supposed to do, which means they can be used to supplement or replace meals.

The European Union recommends that a Meal Replacement should meet the below-mentioned Regulatory Requirements if theyre to qualify as Meal Replacements.

  • Energy: Between 200400 calories
  • Fat: 30% or less than the total energy in the product
  • Protein: 25-50% of the total energy in the product
  • Vitamins and Minerals: 30% or more than that

Also Check: How Much Protein Should I Be Eating To Build Muscle

How To Replace One Meal With A Protein Shake

Lose weight, gain time and potentially boost exercise outcomes by replacing one meal a day with a protein shake. The high protein content in these meal replacement protein shakes curbs your appetite with a meal that’s low in calories.

Living long-term on a meal-replacement protein shake isn’t practical, but it can work for weight loss in the short term. You may also choose to occasionally use a protein shake for the sake of convenience by mixing protein in water for a quick, on-the-go meal.

Video of the Day

Who Should Buy Hlth Code Complete Meal

Meal Replacements or Protein Shakes? Choose Whats Right for You
  • Anyone whos looking for gut health perks from their meal replacement will like the ingredients here.
  • Athletes who have sensitive stomachs may benefit from this replacement shake.
  • Folks who want a formula that contains a blend of proteins, such as egg whites, whey, and hydrolyzed grass-fed collagen.

You May Like: High Protein Snacks For Weight Loss

The Bottom Line Protein Shakes Vs Meal Replacement Shakes

Whether you need to supplement your diet with protein shakes or replace meals with meal replacement shakes depends on what you want to accomplish.

If it is your objective to increase the vitamins and minerals in your diet while increasing your amino acid intake as well, then a meal replacement drink is your best option. If, on the other hand, your objective is to gain weight and put on more mass, then a protein shake supplement can help you do that.

However, because you consume protein shakes does not mean your diet is complete without a meal replacement drink. In order for you to provide your body with the vitamins and minerals it requires, particularly if you are trying to reduce the amount of sugars and carbohydrates you consume, you probably need to be adding meal replacement drinks into your diet.

That is to say, you can replace a meal with a meal replacement shake. But, you can’t replace a meal replacement drink with a protein drink!

They Provide Nutrients That Traditional Diets May Be Lacking

Meal replacement shakes are designed to provide all of the nutrients that you should consume in a complete meal.

When you cut back on calories, it can be difficult to get all of the nutrients you need from your diet.

Shakes are often fortified with nutrients, which might fill your nutrient gap while you are cutting back on calories.

The best meal replacement shakes contain protein, fiber and essential vitamins and minerals.

For example, many commercial shakes are a good source of nutrients such as calcium, potassium, iron and vitamin D, which many people are lacking in their diets.

Bottom Line:

Since meal replacement shakes provide all the nutrients you should be consuming in a meal, they can help you meet your nutrient needs while cutting calories.

Recommended Reading: High Carb And Protein Food

Protein Shakes: Pros And Cons

Pro: they are convenient

Consuming a pre-made or ready-to-mix protein shake is an easy way to get a quick protein boost.

Pro: provides the most benefit for those 50-years and older

As we get older, our muscle mass diminishes. So consuming adequate amounts of protein daily becomes more and more critical. When you hit about 50, protein shakes can help you keep some lean muscle .

Con: they are not nutritionally complete

Unlike meal shakes, protein shakes are not nutritionally complete because they basically only add extra protein to your daily diet. So dont use protein shakes to replace a meal – its just a supplement.

Con: many contain common allergens

Protein shakes often contain common food-based allergens such as milk, egg, and soy. Finding an allergen-free variety can be difficult.

Con: protein shakes can be expensive

Protein shakes can get pretty expensive. There are affordable options available, but these often have less protein per serving and/or contain poor-quality ingredients that could harm your overall health.

Protein shakes are used to build or maintain muscle mass, so theyre typically used by professional athletes, bodybuilders, and self-proclaimed gym rats.

But there are other reasons why you might want to use protein shakes :

  • Needing to maintain your muscle mass as you age
  • Having difficulties meeting your daily protein needs through diet alone
  • Having problems absorbing protein in your intestinal tract

Meal Replacements Vs Protein Shakes: Whats The Difference

Dietary Guidelines : Taking Protein Shakes & Meal Replacements

Protein products and meal replacements differ in nutritional composition and are designed for different goals. To put it simply, meal replacements are designed to help with weight control, while protein drinks are more often used for athletic performance and muscle gain.

Confusing a meal replacement shake with a protein shake is a mistake that could interfere with your weight management goals.

Here is an easy way to understand the two:

Meal Replacement Shakes

  • Intended to substitute one or two meals of your daily diet.
  • Usually fortified with vitamins and minerals.
  • They offer more fiber and carbohydrates than protein shakes
  • They may have more calories per serving than a protein shake, although they are lower in calories than actual meals.
  • Provide protein, but at usually at lower levels than most protein shakes.

Protein Shakes

  • Intended to supplement a regular diet, not to replace a meal.
  • To be consumed before or after a workout.

Don’t Miss: What’s The Difference Between Whey Protein And Isolate Protein

A Quick Warning About Protein And Meal Replacement Shakes

I will always recommend protein and meal replacement shakes to my clients, however, I give them a warning about them. Unfortunately, the food and drug administration does not regulate the supplement industry. Right on their website, they confirm that they dont require supplements to be proven safe.

This isnt to say that these supplements arent safe. There are many reputable supplement companies who pour millions of dollars into creating safe and effective supplements. But there are still companies out there trying to make a quick buck.

When youre shopping for your next protein or weight loss shake do some research and figure out which companies you can trust. I tell my clients to avoid the fifteen to twenty dollar brands like the plague! They may say they contain twenty grams of protein, but many studies have revealed that the label isnt always telling the truth.

I dont want to scare you from investing in supplements only to remind you that there are great ones and then there are bad ones!

Earth Echo Golden Superfood Bliss

Key Information
Working Components: Coconut milk and MCT oil, Turmeric Extract, Black pepper extract, Amla Fruit, Cinnamon Bark, Cardamom, Ginger root, Ashwagandha, and Reishi, Lions Mane, Maitake, and Shiitake mushrooms
Quantity Delivered:
Starting Price: $59.95

Golden Superfood Bliss is a weight-loss supplement and a healthy meal replacement formula formulated from several potent ingredients clinically proven to promote weight loss by dealing with emotional food cravings and unhealthy eating patterns. Supplements work by reducing caloric intake, thereby melting fat deposits and triglycerides rapidly and safely from complex body parts.

With Golden Superfood Bliss, you get 25 calories, 2 grams of saturated fat, and 20 mg of sodium per serving. It also has four mushroom blends ensuring anti-inflammatory benefits for your body.

Earth Echo Foods supplements and superfoods are created to be healthy and environmentally friendly. They provide a wide range of nutrients and weight loss supplements with the most bioavailable, natural components available. This will keep you strong and energetic daily, prepared to give to yourself and the environment.

Starting Price: $37

NatureFuel is a well-known company that makes the best meal replacement shakes. A popular product of theirs is Keto Meal Replacement Shake. The reasons why can be found if you use it.

Recommended Reading: How To Make Protein Cookies

How We Vet Brands And Products

Healthlineonly shows you brands and products that we stand behind.

  • Evaluate ingredients and composition:Do they have the potential to cause harm?
  • Fact-check all health claims:Do they align with the current body of scientific evidence?
  • Assess the brand:Does it operate with integrity and adhere to industry best practices?

Eating a balanced and nutritious diet is the best way to stay healthy, but sometimes a busy lifestyle or other circumstances make it hard to prepare a full meal.

Meal replacement systems are meant to help you get a meals worth of nutrients when you dont have the time or access to enjoy a proper meal.

The most popular alternatives include shakes, bars, and powders. Products high in protein and fiber help increase fullness and satiety, so we focused on products that prioritize these.

You may want to incorporate meal replacement products into your diet to either gain, lose, or maintain your weight. Because they are pre-measured portions in terms of calories, carbs, fat, and protein, they make reaching these goals easier to track.

However, just as everybody has different nutritional needs, not all meal replacements are created equal. Therefore, theres no one-size-fits-all solution when it comes to replacing a meal.

Still, some alternatives may provide you with added energy and nutrients to get you through the day.

About Meal Replacement Protein Shakes

SlimFast Advanced Energy High Protein Meal Replacement Shake, Vanilla ...

Protein is made up of amino acids. Choose a protein shake that offers a “complete” protein, meaning it has a combination of the nine amino acids your body can’t produce on its own.

Protein powders that can be made into meal replacement protein shakes usually contain one or more of the following:

Some formulas, particularly plant-based protein powders, include a variety of proteins to give you the best combination of amino acids.

Don’t Miss: Protein Bars At Trader Joe’s

What Qualifies A Shake As Meal Replacement Vs Protein Shake

In the United States, the term meal replacement is not defined in federal Food and Drug Administration regulations. In Europe meal replacements intended either to supplement or to replace totally normal meals are regulated as to their energy content.

They must provide the following info on the packaging:

  • Intended to use in energy-restricted diets for weight reduction
  • Provide between 200-400 calories
  • Not more than 30% of the calories can be from fat
  • Must not be used for more than 3 weeks without medical advice.
  • Vitamins and minerals have to be at least 30% of the today RDI.
  • Although the US doesnt regulate this market, which is why all of the MLM companies can rip people off by selling low calorie meal replacement shakes, they often follow these guidelines. I do not suggest using these for weight loss.

    I suggest using nutritional shakes as a way to get in your nutrients when a meal is not available or you are in between workouts so you can absorb your nutrients quickly and get back to play. They are a supplement meaning they supplement, rather than replace food.They can come in handy for athletes who need a meal on the go or a replacement between meals. But they shouldnt be used by general population as a meal replacement to reduce calories. You will not feel full from drinking a shake.

    Benefits Of One Shake

    Replacing one meal a day with a protein shake helps you reduce your calorie intake while still promoting optimal nutrient intake. Whole foods tend to be a better option when it comes to getting your protein because they contain additional nutrients ââ¬â such as vitamins and minerals ââ¬â not present in protein shakes. An article published in the Journal of Dietary Supplements in May 2018 confirms that getting your protein from whole foods is superior.

    When you replace just one meal per day with a shake and consume whole foods at other meals, you’re more likely to get all the nutrients you need for a healthy, energized body. For example, have a protein shake for breakfast and then a large salad with grilled chicken at lunch and baked salmon, sweet potato and broccoli for dinner for a balanced, highly nutritious meal plan.

    Also Check: Banana Peanut Butter Chocolate Protein Shake

    Who Shouldnt Buy Kaged Clean Meal

    • Anyone looking for a low carb supplement can find other meal replacements with leaner formulas.
    • Athletes who want more than two flavors to choose from as this meal replacement only comes in Snickerdoodle and Vanilla Cake.
    • If youre looking for a meal replacement that includes probiotics, youll want to look elsewhere.

    Kageds product truly does live up to the Clean Meal name. From digestion to taste, this meal replacement checks most of the boxes on our list, and can truly provide a nutritious meal without any artificial colors or flavors. Many will appreciate how much work each calorie in this formulation can do with regards to keeping them full and providing tons of micronutrients to fill in dietary gaps.

    What Is A Meal Replacement

    Can You Only Drink Protein Shakes and NEVER Eat Food?

    Not to be confused with protein shakes, smoothies or juicing, meal replacements are products intended to replace the nutritional value of a meal but with lower total calorie intake. They include protein along with other nutrients and are often used for weight loss or weight maintenance, with protein to satisfy hunger and manage ones appetite. Depending on the program, they could be used to replace one or two of the usual three daily meals. A protein shake, on the other hand, is primarily intended to deliver protein and is usually designed to add protein to the diet, not to replace a meal.

    As ready-to-eat or easy-to-prepare foods, meal replacements can come in a variety of forms, including meal bars, shakes, and powders that can be mixed with milk. Shakes, in particular, can replace high-fat and high-calorie meals with a measured amount of calories.

    Unlike protein shakes or fruit and vegetable juices, a 200- or 300-calorie meal replacement shake provides both macronutrients and micronutrients typically consumed in a typical 500 to 800 calorie meal.

    Read Also: How To Use Aphogee Two Step Protein Treatment

    Meal Replacement Vs Protein Shakes What Is The Difference

    The health and wellness industry is flooded with tons of products that are supposed to help you get rid of those stubborn pounds. The main staple is typically the latest diet or a weight loss product like meal replacement shakes or protein shakes.

    In todays article, we will discuss the concept of meal replacements and protein shakes. We will talk about what each of these products is and what they are used for and also talk about how they are different from one another since it is very easy to get confused between the two.

    Topic Contents

    Read Also: What Is The Best Protein Powder For Gaining Weight

    Garden Of Life Raw Organic Meal

    Garden of Life offers a raw, vegan, certified organic meal replacement shake with its hallmark 44-superfood blends mixed in.

    Each 115-calorie serving is packed with 100% of your B12 needs and 20 grams of protein, making it a perfect choice for vegetarians and vegans.

    The low caloric content and added fiber make it a great meal replacement for weight loss, too.

    Recommended Reading: Best Egg White Protein Powder

    They May Help You Avoid Unhealthy Meals

    Meal replacement shakes are portable and convenient, and they may help you resist the temptation to indulge in unhealthy processed foods.

    In fact, one of the biggest barriers to losing weight is the time it takes to prepare healthy meals.

    When you are stressed or in a hurry, its much easier to grab a processed convenience food or give in to fast food.

    Unfortunately, typical processed foods can seriously derail your weight loss efforts.

    Most are full of sugar, refined carbs and artificial ingredients, in addition to lacking beneficial nutrients.

    Furthermore, processed foods that are high in sugar, salt and fat activate the pleasure centers of the brain, which can also lead to overeating .

    Conversely, meals made from healthy, whole foods are best for losing weight, but that is not always practical with a busy schedule.

    Meal replacement shakes are easy to drink on-the-go and a significantly healthier alternative to fast foods.

    Bottom Line:

    Meal replacement shakes are convenient. Theyre also a healthier alternative to fast foods.

    Related articles

    Best Protein Meal Replacement Shakes

    Who Shouldnt Buy Ample V ...

    Best Protein Powder For Elderly

    If Protein Is So Important For Elderly People Then Why Isn't...

    Will Protein Make You Lose Weight

    Does Collagen Make You Gain Weight ...

    How To Add Protein To Oatmeal

    Add A Drizzle Of Nut Butter ...